REIGN
Get Reign

Free tool, no signup

Forum, Q&A, or neither of the two you were shown?

Jetonomy, bbPress, Discourse or BuddyBoss forums. Five questions and one answer, with the trade-off written out rather than hidden. We build Jetonomy, so here is the fact that decides a lot of these: Discourse is not a WordPress plugin, and for a very large standalone forum that is a feature, not a flaw.

Short answer: this picker is for anyone adding forums or Q&A to a community, or replacing the forum they have. It weighs the shape of your discussions, whether the forum must sit inside WordPress, your moderation load, your budget and any content you need to move, then names one option and where it falls short.

Options compared
4
Run inside WordPress
3 of 4
Ours in the list
Jetonomy, first row

Five questions

The result updates as you answer. Question 5 is the one that decides most real cases, because moving existing discussion content is the expensive part of any forum change.

Question 1 What shape are the discussions?
Question 2 Does the forum have to live inside WordPress?
Question 3 How much moderation will this need?
Question 4 Budget for the forum software, per year
Question 5 Do you have existing forum content to move?

The four side by side

Three of these are WordPress plugins and one is not. That single row explains most of the disagreement between forum comparison pages.

Option Where it runs Cost Discussion format Best fit
JetonomyOurs Inside WordPress Free to install, with an optional Pro plan. Spaces, threaded discussions, Q&A with accepted answers, voting, reputation, and a moderation queue. Wants forums and Q&A in the same site, styled by the theme, without buying an add-on.
bbPress Inside WordPress Free. Classic threaded forum. Already has years of bbPress topics and no reason to move them.
Discourse Separate application, hosted or self-hosted Self-host it, or pay for their hosting. Threads, with Q&A style topics. The forum is the product, at large volume, with a real moderation team.
BuddyBoss forums Inside WordPress, inside their platform Bundled with BuddyBoss Platform, sold as a yearly platform and theme subscription. Threaded forums tied to their member data. Already running BuddyBoss Platform.

Jetonomy pricing comes from our own store data. Third-party prices are the published starting price at the time of writing and should be confirmed on the vendor site.

How this tool decides

The picker adds points for each of four options across five answers and shows the highest. It is written to let Jetonomy lose. When scores are equal, the tool picks the option earlier in its order, and Jetonomy is last, so a tie never resolves our way.

Question one is the shape of the discussion. Questions with one accepted answer favour Jetonomy and Discourse. Open threads favour bbPress. A mix favours Jetonomy. Question two is whether the forum has to live inside WordPress. A firm yes takes Discourse out of the running completely, because it is a separate application, and says so in a note. Question three is moderation. Light moderation favours bbPress. A review queue favours Jetonomy, and heavy staffed moderation gives Discourse a large lead.

Question four is budget, and it moves points between the free options and the paid ones. Question five is existing content, and it often decides the result. Years of bbPress topics give bbPress a big lead. An existing BuddyBoss or BuddyPress forum gives BuddyBoss forums a lead. If there is nothing to move, Jetonomy gains a little. The tool also shows notes when your answers point at a trade-off, such as heavy moderation when Discourse did not win.

What matters when you choose a forum

Start with the content you already have. The real cost of changing a forum is not the licence. It is moving topics, keeping links alive and keeping members' history. If a forum works, staying is a legitimate answer.

Then think about where the forum sits. If it is a section of your site, with the same login, the same design and the same member profiles as the rest, a forum inside WordPress is the natural choice. If the forum is the product and runs at high volume with a moderation team, a standalone application can be better, at the cost of a separate address, theme and login.

Then think about the kind of conversation. A support community wants questions with accepted answers, so that the next person finds the fix. A discussion community wants open threads. Many communities want both, in different spaces. Last, think about moderation: how many reports you expect, who reads them and what tools they need.

Where Jetonomy fits

Jetonomy is ours and installs free. The free plugin ships spaces, threaded discussions, Q&A with accepted answers, voting, reputation and a moderation queue. Private spaces are a free visibility option. Reign styles it with no add-on, and it shares WordPress accounts with BuddyNext, Learnomy and the rest of the stack.

The Pro plan adds private messaging, polls, email digests, auto-moderation and analytics. Buy it when a specific limit hurts. The Reign with Jetonomy page goes through what it does, and the community build guide shows how it sits beside BuddyNext and MediaVerse.

It is a WordPress plugin, not a standalone platform. The tool says so, and says when Discourse is the better answer.

When to stay with what you have

Stay with bbPress if you have years of topics and members who know how to use it. Reign styles bbPress. Stay with BuddyBoss forums if you already run the platform, because adding a second forum plugin means paying twice and giving members two places to post. Stay with Discourse if the forum is your product. The comparison with Discourse and the Discourse migration guide cover that move for people who want one site.

What members notice

Members notice whether the forum looks like the rest of the site, and whether they need another login. They notice whether they can find an old answer. Accepted answers and voting make the best reply easy to spot, and reputation recognises helpful members. They notice moderation too: a quick response to a report keeps a forum pleasant to read.

Your next step

Open the demos to see a finished community layout, and import one with the free Reign Demo Installer. Choose the engine behind the community with the community picker, and read the pricing page to see how the plans are structured.

Straight answers

Is Discourse really not a WordPress plugin?
It is not. Discourse is a separate application written in Ruby that you host yourself or pay Discourse to host. There are bridges for single sign-on and for embedding comments, but the forum lives at its own address, with its own theme and its own upgrade path. Any page that lists it next to bbPress without saying that is being unhelpful.
When is your own plugin the wrong answer?
Three cases, and the tool will tell you all three. If you already have years of bbPress content, the migration usually costs more than you gain. If the forum is the whole product at very large scale, Discourse is built for that. And if you already run BuddyBoss Platform, their forums are already paid for.
What does Jetonomy cost?
Free to install, with an optional Pro plan. Free covers spaces, threaded discussions, q&a with accepted answers, voting, reputation, and a moderation queue. Pro adds private messaging, polls, email digests, auto-moderation, and analytics.
Can I run a forum and a Q&A section at the same time?
Jetonomy is one plugin covering both: spaces, threaded discussions, q&a with accepted answers, voting, reputation, and a moderation queue. So a support space can run as Q&A with accepted answers while a general space runs as ordinary threads.
Do I need a Reign add-on to style the forum?
Not for ours. Jetonomy is built by the same team as Reign, so its pages inherit the theme rather than needing a styling add-on. The theme itself is one flat licence per site, with no per-member fee.
Where do these prices come from?
Jetonomy pricing is read from our own store data, so it cannot go stale on this page. Third-party prices are set by their vendors and should be confirmed on the vendor site.
What is the best forum plugin for WordPress?
It depends on the discussion and on what you already have. Jetonomy is our free forum and Q&A plugin for new sites. bbPress is the classic option and the right one if you have years of topics. BuddyBoss forums are already included if you run their platform. Discourse is a separate application, not a plugin.
Can I get Q&A with accepted answers on WordPress?
Yes. Jetonomy free includes Q&A with accepted answers and voting, along with spaces, threaded discussions, reputation and a moderation queue. bbPress is a classic forum without accepted answers or voting.
Can I move my bbPress forum to Jetonomy?
It is a migration, so treat it as a project: topics, replies, users and permalinks all have to survive. If your bbPress forum works, the tool will tell you to stay. Reign styles bbPress, so the design can change without the engine.
Does the forum picker always recommend Jetonomy?
No. Years of bbPress content wins for bbPress, an existing BuddyBoss platform wins for its own forums, and a very large standalone forum with a staffed team wins for Discourse. Ties never resolve our way.

One theme, the whole site

See what you can build with Reign, then try it.

Reign is the WordPress theme for building a complete community site: social network, courses, member directory, marketplace and job board on one install. Start with one, add the others when you need them, and keep one login for every member. Open a live demo, or launch a sandbox and get a fresh WordPress site to click through in about a minute.

Add more when you need it

Not sure which setup fits your site?

Tell us what you want members to do on your site. We will tell you which Reign setup, plugins and kit fit, before you buy anything.

What customers say on Trustpilot

Perfect themes

I purchased Reign theme from Wbcom Designs, the support team was very helpful and I got the perfect website what I was looking for. Good work Wbcom Designs

Monika SinghIN